Strength comparison between mild steel pipe and carbon steel pipe

In the extensive field of steel applications, mild steel tubes and carbon steel pipes are two commonly used and significant types of piping. Their strength characteristics directly influence their scope of application and overall performance. A detailed exploration of their strength differences is crucial for making informed material selection decisions in various engineering scenarios.

Union Steel Industry Co., Ltd is professional carbon steel seamless pipe manufacturer, for more details, please contact:sales@union-steels.com

Relationship Between Chemical Composition and Basic Strength

1. Mild Steel Tube

Mild steel tubes have a low carbon content, typically ranging from 0.05% to 0.25%. Carbon is a key element that determines steel strength. The lower carbon content results in a lower proportion of pearlite and a higher ferrite content. Ferrite provides good toughness and ductility, but its strength is relatively low. Therefore, from a chemical composition perspective, the basic strength of mild steel tubes is lower.

2. Carbon Steel Pipe

Carbon steel pipes generally have a carbon content between 0.25% and 0.6%. The higher carbon content increases the proportion of pearlite, which consists of alternating layers of ferrite and cementite, forming a high-strength microstructure. As a result, carbon steel pipes have greater inherent strength than mild steel tubes at the fundamental material level.

Effect of Heat Treatment on Strength

1. Mild Steel Tube

The strength improvement of mild steel tubes after heat treatment, such as quenching, is less pronounced compared to carbon steel pipes. This is because their low carbon content limits the formation of martensite (a high-strength phase) during quenching. For example, under identical quenching conditions, the hardness increase of a mild steel tube may be only 20-30 HRC, whereas a carbon steel pipe could achieve 40-50 HRC.

However, mild steel tubes can undergo surface hardening through carburization or other chemical heat treatment methods. This improves surface hardness and wear resistance, but the enhancement in overall strength remains limited.

2. Carbon Steel Pipe

Carbon steel pipes are more responsive to heat treatment. During quenching, the austenite structure in carbon steel pipes rapidly transforms into martensite, significantly increasing strength. For example, after quenching and tempering, the yield strength of carbon steel pipes can increase from 300-400 MPa to 600-800 MPa.

Additionally, proper tempering can improve toughness while maintaining strength, preventing excessive brittleness and making the material capable of withstanding higher loads and impacts.

Strength Performance in Practical Applications

1. Mild Steel Tube

Mild steel tubes are widely used in applications where high strength is not a critical requirement. For example, in indoor water supply and drainage systems, working pressure is generally low, and mild steel tubes provide sufficient strength to withstand static and flow pressure. Their good ductility also facilitates bending and connection during installation.

In the architectural and decorative sector, mild steel tubes are used for indoor handrails, railings, and similar structures. Their ease of fabrication allows them to be shaped into various forms, and their strength is adequate to withstand normal human leaning and minor impacts.

2. Carbon Steel Pipe

Carbon steel pipes perform exceptionally well in applications requiring high pressure resistance and load-bearing capacity. For example, in oil and gas pipelines, they must endure internal fluid pressure and external environmental forces such as soil pressure and seismic activity. The high strength of carbon steel pipes ensures safe and reliable operation under such demanding conditions.

In mechanical manufacturing, carbon steel pipes are often used for shafts and structural components that need to withstand high torque and impact forces. After appropriate heat treatment, they offer sufficient strength to meet industrial requirements.

Conclusion

In summary, mild steel tubes and carbon steel pipes each have distinct strength characteristics and play essential roles in different applications. When selecting materials for engineering projects, it is crucial to fully consider the operating environment, required mechanical properties, and cost factors. By weighing the pros and cons, engineers can make scientific and well-informed choices, ensuring that material performance aligns perfectly with engineering needs, ultimately contributing to safe, efficient, and sustainable construction and manufacturing.