ASTM A335 P11 vs P22 seamless alloy steel pipes

ASTM A335 is a widely used specification for seamless ferritic alloy steel pipes, specifically designed for high-temperature and high-pressure environments. This standard covers both low alloy and high alloy steel grades, making it ideal for applications such as power station boilers, petrochemical processing, and high-temperature pipelines.

Among the various grades defined in ASTM A335, P11 and P22 are two of the most commonly used chromium-molybdenum (Cr-Mo) alloy steels. These two grades are both designed for elevated temperature service but exhibit distinct differences in chemical composition, mechanical properties, temperature limits, and typical usage scenarios. The following is a detailed comparison of the two.

Union Steel Industry Co., Ltd is professional steel pipes manufacturer, for more details, please contact:sales@union-steels.com

1. Chemical Composition Comparison

Key differences:

The higher Chromium (Cr) and Molybdenum (Mo) content in ASTM A335 P22 significantly enhances its oxidation resistance and creep strength at elevated temperatures, making it ideal for high-temperature and high-pressure environments.

In contrast, ASTM A335 P11 contains a lower alloy composition, which results in reduced high-temperature performance but offers the advantage of lower material costs, making it suitable for moderate temperature applications where cost efficiency is a priority.

2. Mechanical Properties Comparison

Key differences:

Temperature Resistance and Operating Conditions

P11 Pipe Performance

Service Environment: Medium-temperature and high-pressure conditions such as petrochemical pipelines.

Maximum Operating Temperature:

Continuous Use: Up to 540°C

Short-Term Use: Tolerates up to 560°C

Creep Resistance: Not recommended for applications with a design temperature above 550°C, as it lacks specified endurance strength at that range.

P22 Pipe Performance

Service Environment: Suitable for high-temperature, high-pressure applications, including supercritical power boilers.

Maximum Operating Temperature:

Continuous Use: Up to 580°C

Short-Term Use: Tolerates up to 620°C

Creep Resistance: Improved due to higher Cr and Mo content, even though the standard doesn’t specify exact values at 550°C.

3. Heat Treatment Process Comparison

P11 Heat Treatment

Process: Normalizing at 900–950°C, followed by tempering at 650–750°C

Purpose: Enhances ductility, toughness, and structural stability

P22 Heat Treatment

Process: Normalizing at 900–950°C, followed by tempering at 680–750°C

Purpose: Improves high-temperature strength and creep resistance

Note: Slightly higher tempering temperature ensures greater thermal stability

4. Application Scenarios Comparison

P11 Alloy Steel Pipe Applications

Power Generation: Subcritical boiler components such as low-temperature superheaters (<540°C) and moderate-temperature superheaters (540–560°C)

Petrochemical: Medium-pressure steam pipelines, heat exchangers

Other Uses: Hydrogenation reactor feed lines, furnace tubes

Key Advantage: Cost-effective solution for applications ≤550°C

P22 Alloy Steel Pipe Applications

Power Plants: Superheaters, economizers (especially in high-temperature sections), headers, and main steam lines in ultra-high-pressure and subcritical boilers

Petrochemical Industry: High-temperature steam transport and corrosive media handling

Key Advantage: Excellent tensile strength, oxidation resistance, and creep resistance under temperatures up to 600°C

Corresponding domestic and foreign brands:

‌

Which One to Choose: P11 or P22?

Choose P11 for moderate temperature and cost-sensitive projects with less demanding creep strength requirements.

Choose P22 when your system operates at higher temperatures, or when creep and oxidation resistance are critical for long-term stability and safety.

Conclusion

Both ASTM A335 P11 and P22 pipes serve critical roles in high-temperature and high-pressure piping systems. P11 is ideal for medium-range temperatures and offers economic value, while P22 provides superior high-temperature performance due to its enhanced chemical composition and heat treatment profile.

When selecting between P11 vs P22, consider the specific operating temperature, pressure conditions, and material budget to determine the most suitable alloy steel pipe for your project.